Do Not Make Me Choose

Freya and Macy both have a thing for their stepdad, Scott. He swears that every now and then, he can feel them looking at his cock, seeing if they can make out a bulge in his pants. Scott tries not to think much of it, given they’re his stepdaughters, and doing anything with them would be completely insane. Still, both Freya and Macy are incredibly hot and are always flaunting their fit, petite bodies. The girls are constantly wearing skimpy clothes and letting their ass cheeks peek out from their skirts. Scott had never really thought about it, but were they trying to get his attention? His suspicions are confirmed one morning unexpectedly. Freya sits on the countertop, wearing a tiny skirt and a cute pair of panties. She eyes Scott hard and doesn’t stop until she has his attention. She then does the unthinkable and pulls her panties aside, revealing her perfectly pink and tight little pussy. Scott is flabbergasted but can’t make a scene with Macy right there. Freya continues to tease her stepdaddy, trying to get him to touch her pussy. Nothing would turn her on more than her stepdaddy rubbing her clit right in front of her stepsister. She wants to make Macy jealous and prove she’s stepdaddy’s favorite girl. But Scott isn’t giving in to her whims. Not until they’re alone, that is. When Macy leaves the room, Freya teases her stepdad even harder and brings his hand to her pussy so he can feel how wet she’s getting. Freya then takes things way farther when she hops off of the counter, gets on her knees, and pulls Scott’s dick out from his pants. She’s an expert cock sucker, which blows Scott’s mind even more. He knows what he’s doing is wrong, but getting his cock sucked by his stepdaughter is easily the hottest thing he’s ever experienced. She slobbers and gags all over his dick and talks dirty to him the entire time. She wants to make him cum and drain every last drop he has. Scott can feel the sexual desire radiating off of Freya and lets himself give in more and more to the taboo fantasy. When he busts his load, Freya takes it all like a champ, wanting to prove herself to her stepdad. Scott can’t get the blowjob off of his mind. He continues to fantasize about his stepdaughters while they’re finishing up classes, thinking about what it might be like to fill up and dominate them. When the girls get home, they head to the backyard to swim in the pool. Macy finds herself alone with Scott this time and wants a little stepdaddy-stepdaughter time for herself. Scott once again is baffled when Macy gets on her knees to suck his dick. He was getting a blowjob from each of his stepdaughters on the same day, and despite knowing it was completely fucked up, he loved it. Macy doesn’t want the fun to stop there - she pulls down her swimsuit bottoms and shakes her ass in Scott’s face, begging her stepdaddy to fuck her right then and there. Scott knows he shouldn’t, but as Macy lowers her hips onto him and gently pushes her pussy lips against the tip of his cock, he can’t resist. Freya catches them and wants in on the action. They want Scott to choose which is the favorite and most talented stepdaughter. But how could he pick when both of them were so slutty and willing to do whatever it takes to please him. In the bedroom, Scott has his chance to fuck both girls. Their pussies are much tighter than his wife’s, and their youthful sexual energy is absolutely mesmerizing. They each get a turn to bounce on their stepdaddy’s dick, and once they find their rhythm, the stepsisters don’t care about Scott choosing a favorite anymore. They just want to fuck and get their pussies filled. The girls had never fantasized about each other sexually, but now, seeing each other’s naked bodies, they’re even more turned on. They kiss passionately and eat each other out as they get fucked. The sex was pure bliss and a threesome that could never be beat, as the energy in the room was electrifying. Scott cums hard for his sweet stepdaughters, and they share a kiss, swapping his cum and savoring every last drop.